Gransnet forums

Chat

Prince Andrew

(917 Posts)
Lilypops Sat 16-Nov-19 22:42:02

Having just watched the interview with Emily Maitlis, I just cannot make my mind up about him , I find it strange that he could not recollect having that photo taken with the girl with his arm around him , I thought he was very cautious with his answers, What do you all think ?

Gonegirl Tue 26-Nov-19 12:45:42

I can't see anything about paedophilia and the forces in trishers posts. confused

trisher Tue 26-Nov-19 12:36:29

merlotgran someone has posted earlier in this thread that Andrew wasn't popular with other officers so he obviously didn't take that on board (Oh sorry just realised that's a bit of a joke)!

merlotgran Tue 26-Nov-19 12:32:42

If anything, a spell in the RN should have tempered Andrew's arrogant behaviour. He had to be part of a team and fight alongside his fellow officers and ratings, relying on their training and support for his very survival.

Prince Harry's active service was character forming and the Invictus Games is a result of the profound effect it had on him.

I have a feeling that post RN, Andrew quickly reverted to the pampered, selfish individual he's always been.

trisher Tue 26-Nov-19 12:27:56

Callistemon I leave you to work out why you immediately construed my comment as linking the armed foces with child abuse.
I hope I have always found it somewhere within me to have some sympathy with every human being. It is after all one of the best characteristics of humanity.
Annie I so agree but I am trying to maintain sympathy for you.

Anniebach Tue 26-Nov-19 12:18:15

Nice respectable people can become nasty and aggressive if not in a position of power.

Callistemon Tue 26-Nov-19 12:16:21

If you chose to draw that conclusion perhaps it says more about you and your life experiences than it does me.

When in a pit, why keep digging trisher?
The insults are coming thick and fast - now insulting all the posters who questioned your first post!!^

First you say you have a certain amount of sympathy for Andrew - does that say more about you and your life experiences than it does the rest of the posters who disagreed with you?
Add a spell in the army and the possibility of disaster increases.
He was in the Royal Navy but perhaps you don't understand the difference
The disaster is that he associated with a convicted paedophile who trafficked very young girls - therefore you were inferring that being in the Armed Forces somehow led to disasters like this.

No, there is no link, only in your mind.

We could deduce from that kind of link that all communists are mass murderers.
Which is simply not true either.

trisher Tue 26-Nov-19 11:12:58

OMG some of the assumptions made and the extreme conclusions drawn by some on this thread are amazing. Firstly I never suggested that the armed forces were linked to paedophilia (and as I understand it PA would not even be guilty of any such offence in this country, the age of consent being 16 not 17). If you chose to draw that conclusion perhaps it says more about you and your life experiences than it does me. I did say that the armed forces are not appropriate or good places for some people to spend time. I would imagine there are many jobs that do not suit some people and that only reinforce existing damage rather than helping to change attitudes So I am certainly not going to apologise for anything I said. The only thing that would make me apologise would be some definite proof that his service helped PA change his attitudes and become a better person and we all know there isn't any.
It constantly amuses me that all the supporters of the RF are up in arms about this whole thing. What on earth do they think happens when you elevate someone to the status of RF? Even perfectly nice respectable people can become nasty and agressive if they are put in a position of power.

Callistemon Tue 26-Nov-19 11:03:47

It has been reported that Andrew insisted on going ahead with the interview despite advice from Beatrice and a close aide, a PR man who has now quit.

Gonegirl Tue 26-Nov-19 10:56:14

No! The Queen wouldn't be jealous of Charles!

merlotgran Tue 26-Nov-19 10:55:58

Those reports have now been discounted, Anniebach

I think there's been a degree of 'making it up as they go along'

merlotgran Tue 26-Nov-19 10:54:32

Sad that Charles has never really had the support of his parents in his endeavours. Philip has only thinly disguised his disappointment and I've often wondered if there's a touch of jealousy where the Queen is concerned.

Anniebach Tue 26-Nov-19 10:52:25

It has been reported Beatrice and Fergie encouraged him to
hold the interview

Callistemon Tue 26-Nov-19 10:50:03

Thank goodness Charles is the older brother.

Callistemon Tue 26-Nov-19 10:49:14

Apparently Beateice is distraught as she tried to advise against That Interview.

I do feel sorry for his daughters.

merlotgran Tue 26-Nov-19 10:47:34

So would I, Gonegirl

#shithittingfan

Gonegirl Tue 26-Nov-19 09:58:01

Today Prince Andrew comes face to face with Charles for the first time since this kicked off. Would love to be a fly on the wall.

Callistemon Tue 26-Nov-19 09:51:35

specki4eyes it was trisher who made the link between the Army, so-called macho men and paedophilia and caused the digression.

I think she should apologise as she is wrong and that is an insult to all who served and are serving in our armed forces.
Our fathers, our grandfathers, husbands, sons and daughters.

Alexa Tue 26-Nov-19 09:19:57

I like the idea of monarchy by family dynasty.

The children can be reared and educated to the job along with its special moral requirements as with some families with medical tradition, or deep sea fishing, or farming.

The royal family is not up to date. It is too much a family of silly aristocrats where it should be a family of service where service is required even serving in a badly paid job such as nursing. If the Duke of York was not intellectually fitted for a posh job he should have done some lowly manual job or perhaps served in the back room of some charity such as Shelter.

Prince Charles seems to have an idea of the meaning of 'service'. He will be a good monarch as is his mother. He will need to stop killing animals for fun.

If our head of state were an elected one we could not have got a better one than Elizabeth Windsor.

Anniebach Tue 26-Nov-19 09:14:14

The queen see it as her duty until she dies. Did she not make this promise when she was 21 ?

She is not responsible for the actions of a 60 year old son.

I agree about Charles. The queen could make him Prince
Regent but I doubt she will.

specki4eyes Tue 26-Nov-19 09:07:07

Talk about "I digress"! We were discussing Prince Andrew's disingenuous interview, what it revealed and whether he is morally entitled to his position in our society. So up pop those Gransnet posters who like to morph every subject into phsychobabble.
As if all the men who REALLY fought and REALLY suffered and risked their very lives for our country in combat could cite that as being a reason to seek out underage girls to violate! Please!
Queen Elizabeth has fulfilled her duty to the country. As we are a sovereign nation, she should hand over the reins to Prince Charles who, after his early unfortunate choice of bride, has proved in spades that he cares for the people, the environment and nature. The RF needs to become worthy of the respect it is afforded.

Alexa Tue 26-Nov-19 09:05:32

My father could not sweat, as explained by my mother.

SueDonim Tue 26-Nov-19 00:11:29

I'm disgusted at the implication that serving in the armed forces is linked to paedophilia.

My dh was in the Royal Navy for fourteen years yet he's nothing but a great big teddy bear. :heart: His own father joined the RAF at 15 and served throughout WW2 but if anything, he was an even bigger teddy bear.

Trisher should be ashamed of herself.

Callistemon Mon 25-Nov-19 22:03:40

Ooh, I've never watched it, perhaps I'll watch on catch up tomorrow!

I was deadly serious Iam64
wink

Actually, the more I think about it...

Iam64 Mon 25-Nov-19 20:50:09

Naughty Callistemon but, not as naughty as the Gogglebox families watching the programme. I’ve just watched on catch up ?

Callistemon Mon 25-Nov-19 20:12:00

Change of subject:

Re the sweating; has anyone done any research on why people stop sweating, if this harms them in any way and whether this research could help those who sweat excessively?
Perhaps Prince Andrew could offer himself as a guinea pig for such research. It could be groundbreaking.