Gransnet forums

Chat

Shameful confession!

(197 Posts)
sunseeker Sun 28-Apr-19 10:24:16

OK some of you may need to sit down for this one but I have a confession to make.........I didn't like "The Greatest Showman" film shock.

I have tried, honestly, the first time I watched it I switched off after 10 minutes, I tried again last night and switched off after 30 minutes - it is sooooo boring - does anything actually happen in the film?

Now I like musicals, but I also like them to have an interesting story line. As far as I can see it's only redeeming feature is Hugh Jackman wink

I will now go and hide behind the sofa whilst all those who love the film post about what a philistine I am!! grin

dirgni Tue 30-Apr-19 14:06:41

The one that I really didn’t like and couldn’t see the point of was La La Land! Was also totally bored by Nine Perfect Strangers! Didn’t attempt 50 Shades as had negative feedback from my daughter in law!

Theoddbird Tue 30-Apr-19 14:25:34

Can't say I have heard of it.... Who is Hugh Jackman? Not heard of him.... Wanders of contemplating life the universe and everything and everything ..

lincolnimp Tue 30-Apr-19 14:55:35

I can't stand Grease
Ducks to avoid the flack

Maybelle Tue 30-Apr-19 14:58:37

I have never bothered to watch dirty dancing , just doesn't appeal.

Do not like Wizard of Oz, or indeed anything with Judy garland in.

Sara65 Tue 30-Apr-19 15:01:53

Dirty Dancing!!!!
What’s not to like?

blondenana Tue 30-Apr-19 15:25:17

I love Grease and dirty dancing, have seen both lots of times, more the music really than the actual story

TerriBull Tue 30-Apr-19 15:31:17

I love the comments about "Brief Encounter", a couple of friends and I years ago, had the occasional "Brief Encounter" afternoons, watch the film, have a pot of tea and a scone or two and then practice our very best cut glass vowels and British stiff upper lips before collapsing into undignified heaps. Even my mother would utter about the film, bearing in mind it was her era, "awful acting, stilted dialogue and did anyone actually speak like that?" although she did admit liking the Rachmaninov's something or other piano concerto. I think Harry Enfield and Paul Whitehouse were brilliant at doing flickering black and white parodies from those bygone times where everyone knew their place and class grin

Haven't see "The Greatest Showman" I know it's a bit Marmite. Was there ever a film that was hyped up like "La La Land"? all the best bits are in the trailer, the rest is just so...........meh!

notgoneyet Tue 30-Apr-19 15:54:13

Clearly I'm a lost cause! Just started watching 'Showman' today - only managed 15 mins currently but enjoying it so far. Loved Mama Mia, loved Bohemian Rhapsody, loved Les Mis, loved Lady in a Van - though not as a comedy. I thought it was a very sad indictment of society about loneliness and lack of a home in old age.

notgoneyet Tue 30-Apr-19 15:55:03

And Dirty Dancing? My all time favourite film!!

Sara65 Tue 30-Apr-19 15:57:58

You’re easy to please notgoneyet, hope you enjoy Greatest Showman!

Tibbs Tue 30-Apr-19 16:11:06

Didn’t like The Greatest Showman; La La Land or Les Mis. When you see them on TV after they have been out a while you do wonder what all the hype was about

DoraMarr Tue 30-Apr-19 16:13:30

Maw, I think you had better change your identity- dissing Judi Dench? Whatever next!

TwiceAsNice Tue 30-Apr-19 16:16:14

Have never watch Game of Thrones and never will but LOVE Line of Duty. Might start it all again when this series is done

TwiceAsNice Tue 30-Apr-19 16:25:03

Favourite musical of all Jesus Christ Superstar

grannybuy Tue 30-Apr-19 16:30:16

Snap! I even bought the DVD ( unusual for me) as I missed it when it was in the cinema. I just couldn't understand what all the hype was about. I'm going to try watching it again, as first tine round I had three GC's with me, so maybe wasn't concentrating. I felt that there was nothing memorable about the music. I really like musicals (well, most )

grannybuy Tue 30-Apr-19 16:32:46

I see that others, like me, also didn't care for Mama Mia. So corny. Not all well liked music makes for a good film. I'm sure, though, that someone could have come up with a better storyline

Aepgirl Tue 30-Apr-19 16:38:45

No, I didn’t like it either. I think it was good as Barnum. And I found the songs boring and repetitive.

aprilgrace Tue 30-Apr-19 16:56:29

I thought Lala Land was the worst film ever! No plot, no memorable songs. My mum fell asleep.

GloryB Tue 30-Apr-19 17:04:50

This is my first post but I had to write it as I honestly thought that my daughter and me (and Sir Terry Wogan, I heard him mention once on the radio) were the only people who hated Mama Mia..As an 80’s teenager my daughter loved Abba & couldn’t wait to see it. What a let down.

Sara65 Tue 30-Apr-19 17:11:52

I still haven’t seen it Glory, but one of my daughters absolutely loves it!

mrswoo Tue 30-Apr-19 17:13:33

Never read 50 Shades. Never seen Sound of Music. Never intend to read/watch either.

Thought Greatest Showman was ok-ish
Lasted 10 minutes of La La Land
Don’t want to see the new Dumbo because I will always love the original more.

Could happily watch Blood Brothers again and again but my very favourite musical has to be Fiddler on the Roof. I have lost count of the times I have seen it both the stage production and the film.

Sara65 Tue 30-Apr-19 17:22:38

Does ANYONE like LaLa land?

Rosina Tue 30-Apr-19 18:13:29

Well...I didn't find it very good either. I also got bored with 'Mama Mia' and I haven't seen any episodes of 'Game of Thrones'. Clearly a social misfit and from now on, having admitted this, an outcast.

GabriellaG54 Tue 30-Apr-19 18:21:36

The last films I saw were This Is Cinerama, in Bradford and Top Gun at an outdoor screening at Peckham Rooftop cinema.
I don't much like cinemas.

Grandmama Tue 30-Apr-19 18:42:59

Never heard of it!!