Gransnet forums

Chat

Shameful confession!

(197 Posts)
sunseeker Sun 28-Apr-19 10:24:16

OK some of you may need to sit down for this one but I have a confession to make.........I didn't like "The Greatest Showman" film shock.

I have tried, honestly, the first time I watched it I switched off after 10 minutes, I tried again last night and switched off after 30 minutes - it is sooooo boring - does anything actually happen in the film?

Now I like musicals, but I also like them to have an interesting story line. As far as I can see it's only redeeming feature is Hugh Jackman wink

I will now go and hide behind the sofa whilst all those who love the film post about what a philistine I am!! grin

Day6 Sun 28-Apr-19 17:02:16

Christopher Nolan - Director of the dreadful (imo) Dunkirk.

"Best known for his cerebral, often nonlinear, storytelling, acclaimed writer-director Christopher Nolan was born on..."

This (above) is why many people feel they have to fawn and critics give rave reviews. Heaven forbid they don't know greatness when they see it.... hmm I thought the film didn't do justice to the event or people/heroes of it. And as for the soundtrack drowning out everything..

Why was LaLa land so hyped up? That was a bit of a damp squib too imo. A real non-starter.

I didn't feel much for the Greatest Showman either. It was OK, but quite schmaltzy imo, and intended to appeal to a younger audience. I have friends who rave about it. Hugh Jackman is always watchable imo.

DanniRae Sun 28-Apr-19 17:03:32

Oh MOnica I loved 'Brief Encounter'. It was made many years ago and that's how they liked their films and I was happy to immerse myself in that era!

Alima Sun 28-Apr-19 17:25:25

Brief Encounter is on iplayer at the mo. I’m off to watch it again, love that film.........

mcem Sun 28-Apr-19 17:29:02

I agree with maw that "underwhelming" is the word for Greatest Showman and Mamma Mia 2.
Thoroughly enjoyed Wicked and love Les Mis - the film just once but I've lost count of the number of times I've seen it on stage. I'm sure I'll right in saying.u

mcem Sun 28-Apr-19 17:31:16

Ooops! (Must've been a fib!)
Was saying that I'm sure the best ever Thenardier was my son!!!

Sara65 Sun 28-Apr-19 17:32:16

I watched it recently on television, agreed the story line is a bit weak, but something comforting about

Sara65 Sun 28-Apr-19 17:33:19

Sorry, Brief Encounter!

Day6 Sun 28-Apr-19 17:41:08

I love Brief Encounter, with all it's terriblys, awfullys, and dreadfullys in the dialogue! {grin]

Absolutely love that plummy way of speaking. OH and I often have a laugh speaking to each other like that. "You were frightfully decent about that dreadful wine..."

I love most old black and white films. 'Now Voyager' with Bette Davis is my favourite. (We used to watch many of them with my Mum on BBC2 on Saturday afternoons, long after they were made.)

M0nica Sun 28-Apr-19 18:01:21

KatyK, at last, until now I thought I was alone in the world. Even my nearest and dearest, have deserted me on this subject and just suggest I lie down until I feel better!

ninathenana Sun 28-Apr-19 18:13:29

A friend of mine has booked to see 'Wicked' for the 6th time shock I've not seen it.
Another friend is going to watch 'Rivet Dance' for the 4th time. Now just the idea of that makes my eyelids droop.

KatyK Sun 28-Apr-19 18:40:13

Well there are two of us now Monica !

KatyK Sun 28-Apr-19 18:41:21

I have to confess to having seen Blood Brothers five times and Buddy four. blush

BlueBelle Sun 28-Apr-19 18:52:02

I love Blood Brothers and Les Mis I must like the darker musicals don’t like the light and Disney like ones unless they are made for young kids then they are ok but if they are Disney like for adults oh the saccharine gets on my nerves

BlueBelle Sun 28-Apr-19 18:52:59

Th musical I disliked most was Cars just didn’t ge5 it at all

annodomini Sun 28-Apr-19 19:25:42

What a treat to find others who can't stand 'Brief Encounter'. I've never been able to sit through it without getting 'twitchy'! I also confess to never having sat through 'The Sound of Music'.

KatyK Sun 28-Apr-19 19:35:08

Do you mean Cats Bluebelle ? DD and me left at the interval. Awful.

lfc4eva Sun 28-Apr-19 19:50:28

I'm another that didn't rate it as one of my fave musicals... couldn't understand why everyone loved it... I did try... my very best... LaLa Land on the other hand I absolutely loved ( and every time i watch it ... i love it more n more) and everyone I knew hated it............ Maybe I'm just a wee bit weird

chickkygran Sun 28-Apr-19 20:59:04

sunseeker, have enjoyed this thread - I nearly walked out of Greatest Showman, I was with my husband and we just ended up laughing we disliked it so much. Like you with 50 Shades, started to read it, dreadful, but what a winner for the author! Don't let's start on the 50 Shades Films .............

Sara65 Sun 28-Apr-19 21:03:15

Well certainly some very diverse views about Greatest Showman!

But I LOVED it!

Menopaws Sun 28-Apr-19 21:17:25

Nina presuming you mean river dance I reluctantly saw lord of the dance with Michael flatly and have to say it was incredible live, the precision and energy was breathtaking so I was proved wrong as thought it would be boring

notanan2 Sun 28-Apr-19 21:46:16

Oh its awful... totally fluffed up an awful man and sad lives of the circus acts.

... and then it has those damn catchy songs that you end up singing along to even though you hate them!

notanan2 Sun 28-Apr-19 21:49:49

I enjoyed Wicked. Not enough to see it multiple times but enjoyed the show.

I hate Les Mis. Its just "yack". Its the most "luvvie" show on earth... but then so is Cats which I LOVE

I like phantom. I HATED Lion King.

There seems to be no rhyme or reason to what I enjoy grin

notanan2 Sun 28-Apr-19 22:03:32

Since we are "confessing".... I have one, & its about as low-brow as yiu can get:

Am not a big disney fan so surprised myself when I was blown away by the beauty and the beast stage show! I was mesmerised by how the live actors moved just like cartoon characters! Loved it!

The only proper Ballet I have been to was Nutcracker. Most tedious couple of hours of my life.

I also hate panto grin So am not quite sure where my tastes lie on the low/high brow spectrum LOL

notanan2 Sun 28-Apr-19 22:11:45

I couldnt read 50 shades, so badly written, and I usually LIKE trashy novels.

LOVE singing in the rain. HATE mama mia, I mean despise it to an irrational degree. Am neutral about frozen, it was everywhere a few years back so I just decided to embrace it I suppose.

Dunkirk doesnt appeal, neither does la la land.

I hate Charlie and the Chocolate factory (and all Rold Dahl actually) both the old and the new version, but quite like the new Alice in Wonderland which is odd because its so similar to the new charlie & chocolate factory.

Maybelle Sun 28-Apr-19 22:17:15

Loved La La Land the first time I watched it, so when it came onto DVD got a copy and watched it agsi . Hated it !
Stopped watching and gave the DVD away.