Gransnet forums

Chat

Critical or just plain rude?

(93 Posts)
PECS Sun 03-Feb-19 22:06:24

Celebrities are in the public eye: actors, TV performers, singers, royalty etc. and , like any one they are open for
criticism of their actions, behaviour or even being bad at what they do.

To be critical of someone's appearance or a physical attribute is not OK in my book ..that is just rude. But I do sometimes see or hear people say they dislike someone because of an aspect of their physical being: funny eyes, squeaky voice, bushy eyebrows etc.

Am I too prissy to think like this?

Theoddbird Wed 06-Feb-19 13:57:00

PECS....I agree...people are too quick to critisize. They should look at themselves first. Nobody is perfect...

Jalima1108 Tue 05-Feb-19 19:42:02

oh no, are you trying to drive me off the thread PECS!!

MissAdventure Tue 05-Feb-19 19:05:18

smile

Lily65 Tue 05-Feb-19 18:44:09

muffin, is it ok to dislike a celebrity for having an enormous arse?

PECS Tue 05-Feb-19 18:18:28

Well you can spell it out to some people..but they still don't get it!

Lily65 Tue 05-Feb-19 15:36:01

Are we not playing scrabble anymore?

PECS Tue 05-Feb-19 14:01:16

muffin people have to accept their behaviours and attitudes might not be appealing to everyone.. celeb or not! e.g. If a person chooses to shoot their mouth off in a state of drunkeness and causes offence..they have to take the consequences!

PECS Tue 05-Feb-19 13:56:24

I find his type of looks appealing.

Jalima1108 Tue 05-Feb-19 13:47:07

Oh Jalima .send me instead of Helen

goes off mutering 'you cannot be serious, you cannot be serious, you cannot be serious' …..

grin

I agree re commenting on face lifts etc rather than natural features which is unkind.

PECS Tue 05-Feb-19 13:42:40

I think commenting on choices people have made..e.g face lifts, over bronzing etc. is different to commeting a natural feature.

PECS Tue 05-Feb-19 13:38:50

Oh Jalima .send me instead of Helen???

Jalima1108 Tue 05-Feb-19 11:32:29

bushy eyebrows etc
Is it OK to say that I loved Denis Healey's eyebrows?

But Johnny Depp's eye makeup is a real turnoff (I would send him to a desert island with Helen Mirren).

Gaggi3 Tue 05-Feb-19 10:10:19

I think I know who you mean, PECS, and it drives us crazy too. Fortunately, don't watch the programme where the offending word occurs so often, but there are at least 2 others where 'thahsands' pops up.

lovebeigecardigans1955 Tue 05-Feb-19 09:38:51

We probably shouldn't but we do - maybe it's just part of the human condition to judge. We tend to understand people who are more like ourselves but not others. I try not to be unkind but I know I have been in the past. We're all the same under the skin after all.

railman Tue 05-Feb-19 09:37:00

Lilyflower How on earth can there be such a thing as .... Middle class manners ... !

Gobsmacked

muffinthemoo Tue 05-Feb-19 00:46:26

is it still alright to dislike a celebrity for being obviously an enormous arse

annep1 Tue 05-Feb-19 00:43:32

KW? M?

Nannytops Mon 04-Feb-19 22:33:17

M

GabriellaG54 Mon 04-Feb-19 20:30:27

Just don't comment on colour.
Anyone who anonymously reports to GNHQ is obviously a KW.

Lilyflower Mon 04-Feb-19 20:22:38

Middle class manners have all but disappeared. It used to be the rule that personal comments were vulgar but in these days of broadcasting the thoughts of ninnies to the nation via social media older people have forgotten ‘the code’ and younger persons never taught it.

Not only do those who criticise the looks of others risk appearing like Yahoos but their increasingly vicious comments slide into the realms of bullying and intimidation.

I have read the recent news stories of nasty comments made online about the Duchess of Sussex with great distaste. Being married to an ex editor and publisher I know that many comments would count as libel (were the royal family to sue - which they never do). Even were it not so, the commenters surely say more about themselves and their upbringing than about their victims, with their ascerbic and ill natured posts.

Lily65 Mon 04-Feb-19 18:17:25

What will happen to us if we do not use the proper name?

Off to The Tower?

MissAdventure Mon 04-Feb-19 18:16:19

She was Middleton when my mum was alive and we had the conversation.

Nanny27 Mon 04-Feb-19 17:52:08

Surely the Duchess of Cambridge, whose maiden name was Catherine Middleton, should be addressed by her correct name.

TerriBull Mon 04-Feb-19 16:52:14

I'm not overly keen on certain women in the public eye who overdo the surgery and end up looking like a Jessica Rabbit caricature and give those who are susceptible to trying to obtain an ideal (not in my book) an unrealistic view of what they think they ought to look like. Katie Price springs to mind I think if she hadn't mucked about with her face and body as much as she has, she'd look okay.

I think some of us will admit to finding voices on certain c'lebs irritating Stacey Dooley won me over on Strictly, but I find her voice very grating. Also Russell Brand, but that's more to do with his grammar, I remember on QT I heard him refer to "them politicians"

DanniRae Mon 04-Feb-19 16:48:58

Surely if we are being rude about someone on tv, for whatever reason, it's ok if we are in our own living rooms? Mind you my daughter tells me off if she hears me saying that I don't like someone on telly because I find their face annoying! Trouble is there are so many who come into that category..........Moi easily irritated, noooooooo!! wink