Gransnet forums

Chat

The Queen at the WI

(104 Posts)
Floradora9 Fri 25-Jan-19 09:46:00

I had to smile at the thought of her majesty attending a WI meeting , I know she has been a member for years but the thought of her taking along her home baking to be judged and her cup for tea. What catagory of competition might she win ?

Jalima1108 Sat 26-Jan-19 13:20:44

it could be worse, you could be a serf annep grin

I hope your husband feels better soon and can give you some tlc in return.

EllanVannin Sat 26-Jan-19 13:18:50

Well apart from being born in this country, like a lot of others I'm still a " Heinz 57 " ! As are the Royal Family.

EllanVannin Sat 26-Jan-19 13:16:10

The same with Wales ( Plaid Cymru ) who advocate republicanism.

annep Sat 26-Jan-19 13:14:30

should say "none so deaf as those who will not hear". I'm a bit foggy this morning as I have M.E. and coping with ill husband this week - without any kind of help. But then I'm only a lowly subject citizen.

EllanVannin Sat 26-Jan-19 13:14:26

We did have a Republic at one time-----it ended in a civil war between the Parliamentarians and the Royalists.

Because Scotland is independent from England the monarchy still remains because the parliamentary leaders have obviously decided to keep the Queen or she'd have been voted out. It's up to those of the Republican party ( SNP ) to get on side with its people in order to vote out the Monarchy.
This hasn't happened, has it ?

Jalima1108 Sat 26-Jan-19 13:13:26

paddyann still keeps insisting that she is a 'subject' though annep. I think it has been explained so many times that is why I said that.

I think that many people have so many misconceptions about how the office of Head of State is run that they come out with statements that bear no relation to how it actually is.

Yes, they have wealth and use that to live their private lives. Taxpayers money is used to fund the duties of the office, exactly as it would if we had a presidential system.

annep Sat 26-Jan-19 13:09:08

Quite true Jalima. None so blind as those who will not see. Perhaps thats why Paddyann gets so frustrated. Because having one special family treated with such enormous privileges is, frankly wrong. full stop. No one is going to suggest a candidate for presidency on this thread to be criticised by royalists. But that doesn't mean the principle is wrong.
I have no objections to someone inheriting money/land that has been earned legitimately. As for the money they allegedly bring in, as Ive said before the end result does not always justify the means.

Anniebach Sat 26-Jan-19 13:01:05

I like Alan Sugar too, but head of the Commonwealth, would all the countries vote for him

Jalima1108 Sat 26-Jan-19 12:51:54

I think the only comparison is the job they have both done.

I rather like Alan Sugar (ducks for cover)

Nonnie Sat 26-Jan-19 12:43:32

Jalima definitely not suggesting him for president, comparing him to Trump! No suggestions at all for president, think it is a bad idea in so many ways. We have quite enough rubbish politicians already.

Anniebach Sat 26-Jan-19 12:18:59

Richard Branson ? No too wealthy

Jalima1108 Sat 26-Jan-19 12:11:27

Does being in the HOL make him a politician though, Nonnie?
Lord Sugar now, exempt from running for president imo.

Nonnie Sat 26-Jan-19 12:08:32

Isn't Alan Sugar the UK equivalent of Trump? Didn't they both host some TV programme?

Nonnie Sat 26-Jan-19 12:07:44

Don't forget that said president would need to attract as many tourists to prop up our economy.

Anniebach Sat 26-Jan-19 12:03:31

And someone who would remain silent if their children , grandchildren were critcised in the media, would only own one car , would give away any wealth or property they had inherited .

Jalima1108 Sat 26-Jan-19 11:56:44

Some alternative suggestions would be interesting - definitely not a tired elderly politician, nor a has-been celebrity.
Or an ex-captain of industry who may be more interested in feathers and nests
An academic who could be biased/inward looking?

Someone who has a keen interest in the Commonwealth and the increasing number of countries who still wish to join?

hmm I am having a struggle thinking of anyone suitable, let alone several if we had to have an election.

Anniebach Sat 26-Jan-19 11:54:32

Do say who you would choose as President PECS should the queen die tomorrow

PECS Sat 26-Jan-19 11:52:28

I know that... and I would prefer not to have royalty. I have no problem with the age or origins of either a president or royal head of state!

Anniebach Sat 26-Jan-19 11:49:22

I don’t want a president PECS

PECS Sat 26-Jan-19 11:46:14

Why is age an issue..or all ancestors British? You just don't want me as your president Annie ???

Anniebach Sat 26-Jan-19 11:42:14

I don’t want a politician as president.

Still no suggestions from the republicans for their choice of president

Can’t be English it would trouble some republicans, has to be British born with all ancestors British born, not wealthy,
age seems to be important to some republicans too.

Jalima1108 Sat 26-Jan-19 11:38:47

I would not want to be a subject either and am happy to be a citizen in a country with a benign monarchial system which fulfils the apolitical role of Head of State, admired around what is an increasingly chaotic world.

Cheaper than an elected president too, I do like a bargain. I also like a sense of continuity than uncertainty - we have enough of that in the political arena without adding to it by having yet another tier of elections to contend with.

Jalima1108 Sat 26-Jan-19 11:28:04

I think it has been pointed out before that you ARE NOT A SUBJECT YOU ARE A CITIZEN.. LOOK AT YOUR PASSPORT IF YOU HAVE ONE.
paddyann and others

Perhaps there is a need to SHOUT occasionally as there are none so deaf as those who don't want to hear.

Nonnie Sat 26-Jan-19 11:20:18

Be afraid, be very afraid if you want a President. Think of the US where the best they could come up with was Trump or Clinton! Why would you think we could do better?

PECS Sat 26-Jan-19 11:13:18

So the debate is not to do with the description of the queen but the word "Elderly* I think you would have still been annoyed if I used the phrase older celebrity!,