Gransnet forums

Chat

friendship and money

(18 Posts)
gillybob Wed 25-Apr-18 23:08:48

My thoughts exactly BlueBelle .

BlueBelle Wed 25-Apr-18 19:01:18

She also doesn’t tell us what ‘treating’ her means ....a cup of coffee, a meal out, a visit to the theatre, or a handout every month ?

Apricity Wed 25-Apr-18 19:00:28

The two most obvious explanations are that money is getting a bit tighter for your friend or that she is tired of the one way treating but doesn't want to say this to you directly. Why would you think that her religious affiliation was the most likely explanation? As others have said maybe time for things to be more reciprocal.

BlueBelle Wed 25-Apr-18 18:58:20

Seems like they are not that close friends or poster would have asked if her friend was ok financially and not be asking us It sounds a very one sided friendship with financial expectations unless Kristine comes back and explains more to us

Oldwoman70 Wed 25-Apr-18 18:58:11

It seems the OP is most concerned that her friend is no longer "treating" her and may be giving her money to her church instead.

grannyactivist Wed 25-Apr-18 18:47:36

I almost get where the OP is coming from.
I have a friend who once came into some money and at the time was very generous to members of my family. Subsequently she's fallen on hard times and ekes out a living from her small income, so when we get together I almost always invite her to lunch and I pay. My friend always offers, never takes it for granted that I will pay, but it's my way of supporting her at the same time as showing her how much I value her friendship - we joke that if she wins the lottery she'll treat me back. If I suddenly stopped I suspect she would wonder why. (Although in our case I think she would ask me if everything is okay and/or I would simply tell her why I could no longer do it.) So I do wonder why you don't just ask your friend if everything is okay financially and offer to help if it's not.

Elegran Wed 25-Apr-18 18:06:29

And I wondered too, particularly as a bit earlier my first thought on seeing another thread called, "Are there any groups of people you always avoid?" had been that it seemed an invitation to discriminate on divisive grounds (like religion).

ninathenana Wed 25-Apr-18 17:36:01

Willow I wondered about the mention of her religion too but didn't want to get into that minefield

Willow500 Wed 25-Apr-18 17:27:34

Depends what you mean by treating you? Why would her religion have anything to do with it either? It could be that at 82 she may be having some health problems and worrying that she might need her money for the future?

ninathenana Wed 25-Apr-18 15:33:32

Sorry if I'm wrong but it seems you expect this. Why else would you query her stopping after "treating you every month for years"
If this is not reciprocated then I would come to a point where I told myself enough !

Nannarose Wed 25-Apr-18 15:27:12

I too am puzzled, but I suspect this wasn't one-sided - otherwise it would be obvious! It may not have been turn-taking exactly - I am thinking of thanks for a favour. Such as allowing someone to park on your drive every night, or providing a regular coffee stop, may then 'treat' you regularly to say thank you.
JWs as a whole don't attempt to control the congregation's money, but being a member may place certain obligations that the friend is finding awkward.

DanniRae Wed 25-Apr-18 14:20:27

Yes, I am puzzled too. I hope krisstine comes back on to explain a bit more about this situation confused

Elegran Wed 25-Apr-18 14:15:03

Have you asked her? Take HER out for a change and say it is because she has treated you every month for such a long time, and you thought it was your turn. Maybe she will tell you why she has stopped.

BlueBelle Wed 25-Apr-18 14:01:16

Agree with others how come you ve let her treat you all this time maybe she feels taken for granted ...I would

paddyann Wed 25-Apr-18 13:31:16

maybe you should offer to treat her for a change ,she may feel she's being taken for granted ..or for a fool .

tanith Wed 25-Apr-18 10:51:23

All sounds a bit odd to me too, maybe she is waiting for you to reciprocate her generosity.

gillybob Wed 25-Apr-18 10:45:01

Not sure what you mean krisstine ?

Are you saying your friend has always “treated you” to something ? ( a gift, a meal out or whatever) and has now stopped . Could it be that your friend can no longer afford to spend money on you or maybe her family have cottoned on that she is spending money on you on a regulars basis . It all sounds a bit odd to be honest .

krisstine Wed 25-Apr-18 10:35:20

This is very difficult subject but my friend who i am very close to has always treated me every month for years

but in the last few months she has stopped and its eating away at me as to why.

She is 82 year old jehovas witness and wondered if they are trying to control her money.

I just wondered what any of you would do.

I