Gransnet forums

Chat

Memorial benches

(152 Posts)
M0nica Wed 14-Mar-18 13:23:18

Someone from the NT in Jersey has expressed concern about the number of memorial benches found at many beauty spots and suggests the number could be limited by only allowing them to be there for a given number of years.

I can only whole-heartedly support this measure. About 5 years ago we went to Whitby, staying in a hotel on the headland opposite the ruined abbey. The view from the headland to the abbey is superb. There was a broad sweep of grass around the headland in front of the hotel and as DH and I wandered along it I counted 67 memorial benches before I freaked out and insisted we went back to the road, crossed it and walked on the pavement as far from the benches as possible. I counted 67, but there were a lot more.

All the benches were so close together, to walk on the headland meant threading between the benches each with their little brass plaque saying that John, or Iris or Fred or Violet who died.... loved this view.

It is left me with a horror of these benches. I can just cope with them, if the bench is where a bench would be anyway, in an alcove in a garden for example, one or two at a popular beauty spot, but anything much more and I start shuddering.

I can see the point of benches, but not the need to mark them with brass plaques. The chances that anyone seeing the plaque to Mildred, or Reg or Joy, will know who they are, are remote and anyone else seeing them, especially in profusion won't care.

When DFdied we made a donation to a new quiet garden at the hospital. We chose a table and when asked whether we wanted a plaque on it DS and I were emphatic that we didn.t - and that was before my stay at Whitby.

lemongrove Sun 18-Mar-18 14:39:55

Actually, a shop is a public space.
It has to be a memorial though durhamjen so you are missing the point.
Besides, I need my money for holidays whilst I am alive.

MissAdventure Sun 18-Mar-18 14:16:07

hmm

durhamjen Sun 18-Mar-18 14:15:24

Go on, then, lemon, do it now. Why wait until you are dead?

lemongrove Sun 18-Mar-18 14:07:28

Why?
Think of all the grateful women ( and the tired bored husband now and then) that would be grateful for a sit down.

durhamjen Sun 18-Mar-18 14:05:02

I can see a difference between a public place and a shop.

lemongrove Sun 18-Mar-18 13:39:48

Thank you smile I thought so too.

MissAdventure Sun 18-Mar-18 13:32:21

I don't see why anything which serves a purpose can't be donated.
Its a lovely idea.

durhamjen Sun 18-Mar-18 13:20:45

" Please don't let your personal antagonism follow on to other thread."

Exactly, chewbacca.

NfkDumpling Sun 18-Mar-18 13:18:31

As someone who, at present, has problems walking very far and cannot stand for any length of time either, memorial benches are much appreciated and Lemon's suggestion of memorial seats in department stores sounds wonderful. What's wrong with it? I cannot shop at the moment precisely because there are no seats. I was so pleased to find one in Lakeland and thanked the manager only to be told he has to hide it round the corner as Head Office doesn't approve. If shopping was the favourite pastime of the deceased then it seems quite apt to me.

Chewbacca Sun 18-Mar-18 11:32:50

I'm sorry for your loss durham, but there are many other posters on this thread who are also bereaved; some of them more recently than you. Lemon posted her initial remark about her comfy chair in Debenhams yesterday and it was met with responses in the vain that she posted ie, humour. Please don't let your personal antagonism follow on to other threads, it's unfair to those of us who have enjoyed contributing to this thread which has, until now, been cheerful, light hearted and friendly.

durhamjen Sun 18-Mar-18 11:25:03

My husband died six years ago, chewbacca, and we have a memorial bench for him.
Sorry if I am taking it a bit more seriously than a chair in Debenhams.

Marianne1953 Sun 18-Mar-18 11:21:54

I love memorial benches, it’s always interesting reading them and relating to the people who also loved the view. Rufford park on Nottinghamshire has loads, family often leave flowers, it’s a feeling that the departed are still enjoying the same places as I am doing.
I was going to have a bench made for my parents in Worthing, however the rip off cost and the fact I live in Scotland, I am going to have a memorial bench for my garden and add all the names of my valued members of my family.

Chewbacca Sun 18-Mar-18 11:08:44

confusedshock That was uncalled for durham, this thread is in "chat", if you haven't noticed and the majority of the posts, thus far, have been light hearted and friendly. Don't spoil it please.

durhamjen Sun 18-Mar-18 10:59:13

Do you always have to trivialise every subject, lemon?

lemongrove Sun 18-Mar-18 10:57:08

I want a small plaque on the comfy chair:
This chair has been donated by Lemongrove who spent many happy hours browsing in this store, this view of the womens wear section was her particular favourite.Enjoy!

lemongrove Sun 18-Mar-18 10:51:40

Yes, anything that makes customers lives easier and keeps them in the store is a good idea.
Small coffee shops with free wifi in stores is a good idea too.

Alexa Sun 18-Mar-18 09:52:02

Lemongrove wrote: "I think I will endow a comfy chair in Debenhams instead,
Whatever happened to customer chairs in shops?"

The defunct Debenhams premises where I live had a open to the rest of the floor cafe from where one could sit at ease and watch the shoppers. This was a winning combination, and there is a marketing opportunity for such facilities in shops. With the decline of the high street it needs an innovative

look at what it can provide.

OldMeg Sat 17-Mar-18 22:09:00

I like that idea ??

lemongrove Sat 17-Mar-18 21:44:06

I think I will endow a comfy chair in Debenhams instead,
Whatever happened to customer chairs in shops?

MamaCaz Sat 17-Mar-18 21:22:53

It's a good job we don't all want them, with over half a million deaths in England and Wales every year!

MawBroon Sat 17-Mar-18 09:47:00

Let me put some of you straight there are no benches up Snowdon sad

I’m not going then ! grin ??

MissAdventure Sat 17-Mar-18 09:37:21

Ah, that's lovely. I hope my mums bench is someone's favourite, for some reason. smile

Alexa Sat 17-Mar-18 09:30:56

Miss A that is just what I do when I sit on my favourite bench and the first name of the dead person is actually Jean!

nightowl Sat 17-Mar-18 08:52:08

I love memorial benches. They make me think about the person who died, and of their family, which surely is one of the reasons they’re there. I would love to think that after I’m gone a small part of me could still be out in the world, in a place I loved, even if it’s only as a memory.

And as a mum and a grandmother I can think of nothing nicer than having a baby lie on me to have its nappy changed. I would hope that some of the love I had for my own babies and grandbabies would somehow transmit to any other little one who came my way.

durhamjen Sat 17-Mar-18 08:38:59

I read in an article in a paper last week that someone had said that the only thing wrong with Ben Nevis was that there were no cafe or seats at the top!