Gransnet forums

Chat

Jesus replaced with a Gregg's sausage roll.

(1001 Posts)
Day6 Fri 17-Nov-17 13:25:32

The Guardian would have us believe that only 'flaky' Christians are likely to be upset by Gregg's depiction of the Nativity, placing a sausage roll in the manger.

So, Christians are 'flaky" (oh so witty, not) to be upset?

I am no longer a church-goer but I was brought up as a Christian, as were many of us I suspect, and I am offended that Greggs think it is OK to offend as they have. Not only that, journalists like this oh so lofty sneering one place the blame for any offence on silly Christians who are obviously not normal if they have faith.

It really sickens me, this media hatred of certain groups when some are beyond criticism.

One journalist suggested all religions are open to parody and it is par for the course. I'd suggest otherwise. Make fun of Mohammed and you'll be blown to smithereens. Think Charlie Hebdo.

The hilarity the defaced manger scene has caused over the internet puzzles me. Greggs in their insensitivity have become the comic heroes and Christians, for believing in Christ's lowly birth, are the idiotic 'right wing' reactionaries, according to left wing media.

I am cross at the power of social media to dictate what we should think, but also on behalf of my truly lovely Christian friends. One told me she has 'turned the other cheek'.

How do you feel?

maryeliza54 Sat 18-Nov-17 10:56:13

Well that’s fine - I don’t respect misogyny or homophobia for example whoever or whatever is expressing it.

maryeliza54 Sat 18-Nov-17 10:54:32

In fact read my post of 10.40 - pretty clear where I stand

sunseeker Sat 18-Nov-17 10:52:55

Really - I think that is where you and I differ, because I would respect the fact they believed something different, as I believe most Christians would.

maryeliza54 Sat 18-Nov-17 10:51:41

In fact I’d have even more to say about Islam

maryeliza54 Sat 18-Nov-17 10:49:04

Yep I would

sunseeker Sat 18-Nov-17 10:47:40

maryeliza If you were on a forum where several people had expressed their faith in Islam - I wonder if you would make the same comments about their religion as you have about Christianity

durhamjen Sat 18-Nov-17 10:46:18

Greggs are very culturally aware. That's why they do all the charity they do in the north east.

They have just been doind a beach awareness programme with the schools up here and Surfers against Sewage. The beaches in the north east are the cleanest they have ever been. Only two have been said to be average, with the rest being good or excellent.
That's cultural, isn't it, whether you leave rubbish around on the beaches, and what you put in the water, just as much as whether you eat sausage rolls or fillet steak.

TerriBull Sat 18-Nov-17 10:41:59

I didn't specifically mention Christian speakers, although if I had the time I would Google that, I may later. However, it's common knowledge that all manner of speakers have not been allowed a platform in our universities, because they've offended some faction or other, obviously not Christians because, as we know, they should suck it all up. Germanine Greer is just one example.

maryeliza54 Sat 18-Nov-17 10:40:06

I really don’t see why for one moment I should respect Christianity or any other set of religious views - homophobia, misogyny,intolerance are/have been rampant for centuries through organised religions. My only rules are that if I visit a religious building I observe the rules in place - anything else is fair game for criticism

sunseeker Sat 18-Nov-17 10:38:15

paddyann I agree with your comments regarding the "mean Scots". However are you not falling into the same stereotype by branding all Christians as uncaring due to your experience of the religious divide you have experienced in Scotland. I married into a different church than my own, there was no question that I would be disowned, neither was my husband by his family. We were welcomed into whichever church we chose to go to - we tended to alternate.

maryeliza54 Sat 18-Nov-17 10:33:40

Which Christian speakers have been banned from which university campuses?

GoldenAge Sat 18-Nov-17 10:31:33

I agree completely with you Day 6 - as an atheist who was brought up in a Christian family, I am not offended by digs as any religion as long as they are not hugely public attacks because as we have seen on several occasions, people who do make digs at Islam are imprisoned, tortured, executed, and other members of society are punished through terrorist attacks. So what's good for the goose is good for the gander I say, and especially as we live in what is still a Christian country all manufacturers and service providers should respect that - just as an aside I bought sausages in Marks and Spencer yesterday and the cashier put his hand inside a plastic bag before he would handle them. I had no problem with that because it showed understanding on the part of the store, and the cashier that people of all religions should be accommodated in a sensitive way so that we can live together. Greggs in my opinion need a sharp lesson in cultural awareness.

TerriBull Sat 18-Nov-17 10:27:49

Yes Paddyann I know the sectarian religious divide exists in parts of Scotland as well as Ireland and as far as Scottish meaness is concerned, I would concede it's annoying to always be lumbered with a hackneyed stereotype. In spite of having many arguments with my catholic parents about their religion, I now feel there is a need to stick up for Christians these days because it seems increasingly that every minority, bar them, are allowed to be sensitive about the most innocuous remarks and issues so much so that speakers are often banned from university campuses and the like. If we are to regress in this way then I think there should at least be a uniformity about it.

Aspidistra Sat 18-Nov-17 10:23:21

Why are people so easily offended these days? The advert was possibly I'll thought through, but "offensive"? Seriously? And I am also fed up of the "they wouldn't dare offend Muslims/Jews etc etc, when offensive stuff is said about them all the time.

Christian Today have the right attitude, and deserve some respect for their excellent response to the Jesus/Greggs sausage roll fiasco:

'There is nothing more humble and down-to-earth than the Greggs sausage roll – it’s inexpensive, unglamorous and the guilty pleasure of a million people who would deny their love of it in front of friends. If you’re going to reach for a metaphor, Jesus was far more sausage roll than fillet steak – even though that’s what the people waiting for him had ordered.'

maryeliza54 Sat 18-Nov-17 10:19:51

I think both those things have everything to do with the issues on this thread - and why are you so uncharitable about Greggs charity - all charitable giving attracts tax relief - are you against all charity. Or is the charitable status that churches have different?

paddyann Sat 18-Nov-17 10:19:15

maybe because "chritians" should focus on things that need done ,instead of this nonsense

Anniebach Sat 18-Nov-17 10:16:32

What on earth has children in need and universial credit to do with a sausage roll in place of the Christ Child in a crib .

Will Greggs benefit from tax relief for their generosity?

durhamjen Sat 18-Nov-17 10:08:45

Greggs made £832,573 for Children in Need.

Lazigirl Sat 18-Nov-17 10:08:22

I was in doctor's waiting room feeling quite stressed and low, and the only other person there was an elderly gentleman. Local radio was on and they reported the "sausage roll incident". We both burst out laughing, and decided there were much worse things happening in the world at which to be offended. I am not a Christian but respect their views, and in the great scheme of things think this is quite petty but has achieved the aim of massive publicity for Greggs.

maryeliza54 Sat 18-Nov-17 10:06:25

I think I’d rather get that god isn’t annoyed btw - I said if there were a god. And thanks so much for allowing me my atheists belief - I think I’ll add patronising to inanity.

lemongrove Sat 18-Nov-17 10:05:26

grin

maryeliza54 Sat 18-Nov-17 10:04:24

Just like Christisns then lemon and do laugh away - you often make my day with the sheer inanity of so many of your posts

durhamjen Sat 18-Nov-17 10:03:43

I've just been reading about reverse advent calendars, where instead of having a piece of chocolate or whatever every day for advent, you put something into a foodbank every day of advent. Sounds a better way to spend £24 than buy Greggs advent calendar., although the £24 at Greggs will go towards its charitable work.
Charity? In the north east?
Whatever next!

Up to 100,000 more families will get no universal credit in December because there are 5 Mondays in the month, just to add another twist to the UC scam.
Extra stuff in food banks definitely needed in the north east.

lemongrove Sat 18-Nov-17 10:03:30

Agree totally sunseeker

lemongrove Sat 18-Nov-17 10:02:04

maryeliza what is it about your posts that always make me laugh?Could it be eternal outrage expressed about others, or the complete OTT ness of the comments. grin
God isn’t annoyed btw but some people with Christian beliefs are.As for a Christian vicar’s comments about the debacle, yes, well, he would turn the other cheek as it were,and yes, Christians in Britain do have a sense of humour, but that doesn’t mean saying and thinking that anything at all is quite ok.
You are welcome to atheist ‘belief’ as long as you recognise that is is just that belief and not provable facts.

This discussion thread has reached a 1000 message limit, and so cannot accept new messages.
Start a new discussion