Gransnet forums

Chat

Why age, not shoe size or the colour of your front door?

(28 Posts)
phoenix Wed 01-Nov-17 20:24:16

Evening all, hope you are all well.

Just watching a quiz programme on TV where each contestant gave their name, age and occupation (in that order).

I've also noticed that radio/television/newspaper reporting also nearly always mention the age of the person concerned.

Why confused

Baggs Sat 04-Nov-17 06:23:51

?

Baggs Sat 04-Nov-17 06:23:22

I think I'm pretty immune to feeling patronised, lizzypop. It hardly ever occurs to me that someone might be trying to patronise me. It is possible that this is because they aren't but are just being natural. One's (rough) age is so visible, one's bricklaying skills not so much.

What you do for a living and how old you are tell people something about you? Not much but more than other 'key' facts might. Quiz padding is all it is.

Oldwoman70 Fri 03-Nov-17 10:27:25

I am not particularly secretive about my age (hence my username!) but don't understand why it seems to be an automatic question on most forms - I tend to say over 21. I may be 70 in chronological terms but inside I am still 25 (although sometimes my body reminds me I'm not!)

Envious Thu 02-Nov-17 23:34:36

Btw way big foot here has a white front door. I just knew everyone was waiting to know.

lizzypopbottle Thu 02-Nov-17 21:02:25

Baggs I forgot to use the word patronising. I don't like being patronised by age related stereotypes. Just me as a product of my dear old dad's example ?

Surely the police will have to stop using the blanket terms male and female in these PC days of so many different genders? If I look like a woman but identify as something else can I sue if they label me as female?

phoenix Thu 02-Nov-17 20:44:21

Watching "The Chase" every contestant introduced themselves in this order:

Name, Age, Occupation.

They are obviously told to do it this way.

BTW, that woman in the red jumper needs a professional bra fitting.

Envious Thu 02-Nov-17 19:23:19

I’m 10.5 plus sales tax......42 and vat in your world. smile

Baggs Thu 02-Nov-17 18:35:17

I think there's a reason why male and female are used, though I don't know what it is. Just thinking that a person can be a manly female or a womanly male (well, not the same person doing both, I suppose, unless they are a VG actor/ress).

Wheniwasyourage Thu 02-Nov-17 17:02:34

Oh yes, watermeadow, me too. The words 'youth' or 'young woman/man' could even be used. Anything other than 'a male' or 'a female'!

My name is Wheniwasyourage and I am 29 + VAT and service charge.

watermeadow Thu 02-Nov-17 16:42:36

Local press reports call anyone over 55 “elderly”
What gives me apoplexy is the police jargon where everyone is a male or a female. MAN OR WOMAN, I shout at the radio or the paper.

Baggs Thu 02-Nov-17 15:48:38

Besides which pigeonholing or stereotyping is actually a useful tool in human relationships and understanding of the world. It's not always a bad thing.

Baggs Thu 02-Nov-17 15:47:11

Also, I don't care if people pigeonhole me. I know they'll get it wrong but I don't see that as a cause for worry.

Baggs Thu 02-Nov-17 15:46:17

If one is a grandmother one has clearly had to deal with stuff. I think the term suggests (rightly or wrongly) that one's had more to deal with and therefore has had more experience of life than, say, a bricklayer. Bricklayer doesn't tell you as much about a person as grandmother or grandfather does.

That doesn't mean a bricklayer hasn't had to deal with stuff just as much as a grandmother just that the connotations of bricklayer are fewer.

Age says something more than various other descriptors too. That's my take anyhoo.

Smithy Thu 02-Nov-17 15:09:11

Age 35 + vat, shoe size 5/38 door soon to be anthracite.

Jalima1108 Thu 02-Nov-17 14:06:39

or 'elderly woman, 72, hits would-be mugger with her umbrella'.
'She is now up on a charge of assault and will appear before magistrates tomorrow.'

lemongrove Thu 02-Nov-17 14:02:20

We would all be referred to as ‘pensioner, Mrs Smith’ in the news.grin
It seems to be a very British thing ( mentioning age) especially in newspapers.

KatyK Thu 02-Nov-17 13:28:06

I get a bit annoyed when they refer to someone as 'grandmother' or 'grandfather' - as in 'grandmother, Mrs Smith, was mugged'. I'm sure there's much more to her than being a grandmother.

lizzypopbottle Thu 02-Nov-17 13:14:06

I agree with Synonymous that reporting someone's age allows the reader to neatly pigeonhole that person and apply hackneyed stereotypes. However, stereotypes should be challenged. Labelling people by age is also carried out by calling them pensioners. Even though pensions may be claimed by people in their 50s, the first idea is 'old age' pension, (happily now, better known as state pension). People are, apparently, avid to know a person's age and some are rude enough to ask outright. I don't ask anyone (including children) how old they are. I think it's because my dad was on a lifelong hobby horse about irrelevant and intrusive, personal questions and partly because I'm not particularly interested. Sometimes, I tell myself that I'm not interested enough. ?

judylow Thu 02-Nov-17 12:29:04

GrandmaMoira, I think it's to elicit sympathy. Grandmother is meant to make the person sound old and frail.

GrandmaMoira Thu 02-Nov-17 09:44:56

Media reports on women also say "mother" or "grandmother", not "teacher" or whatever their job is. It always make me think we only exist because we've had children.

vampirequeen Thu 02-Nov-17 09:32:23

I often wonder why when the media report on a woman they always say things like 'Mary 58'. They rarely say 'Martin 58'. What does her age have to do with things?

Synonymous Wed 01-Nov-17 23:28:38

Phoenix I have a feeling that we are all supposed to be kept in little boxes for identification purposes - and they also have their own little boxes to tick of course!

Jalima love the age being the same as shoe size - having gone all continental of course. grin

pensionpat sadly I don't think we can do anything except reveal our weight unless we become hermits. sad

pensionpat Wed 01-Nov-17 23:10:12

I will reveal anything but my weight!

Jalima1108 Wed 01-Nov-17 22:11:03

Shoe size 39, front door brown. Age the same as shoe size wink

They usually mention the value of someone's property in newspaper reports too.

phoenix Wed 01-Nov-17 21:46:46

I'm not concerned about age being mentioned, just don't understand why it is considered relevant.