Gransnet forums

Chat

Hearing is not what it used to be, Brain 100%

(41 Posts)
Gaggi3 Thu 15-Dec-16 11:28:30

Christie had a problem with his voice, apparently, and couldn't speak any louder. Tim Roth was playing him as he was, supposedly.

annifrance Thu 15-Dec-16 11:15:16

Diction/elocution gone out the window. It used to be taught in schools. There was a rreason why, in the past, it was known as received BBC English. It wasn't posh, just spoken clearly.

HthrEdmndsn Thu 15-Dec-16 11:12:42

Ailma. Tim Roth in Rillington Place was awful. Couldn't hear a word he said!! I could hear everybody else but not the main protagonist.

Alima Thu 15-Dec-16 10:52:43

I will never rate Eddie Redmayne as an actor. I was really looking forward to the BBC adaptation of Birdsong. He ruined it for me, mumbled all the way through. My hearing isn't that bad, if the actors speak properly, the sound engineers put some effort into their work and the background music takes a back seat I can hear everything. Heard every bit of Rillington Place, perfect.

michellehargreaves Thu 15-Dec-16 10:39:24

Totally agree with comments above. I am not deaf but often find myself saying, "what did they say ", to my husband, who has no more idea than I have! Very frustrating. Doesn't help to turn up the volume, because it is then just louder mumbling and louder irrelevant background noise.

Lewlew Thu 15-Dec-16 10:32:18

Ana you are so right about BBC in particular. I have seen letters in newspapers about this. The background music and other effects (eg a trotting horse clip-clopping, or a motorcycle engine) are too loud, and the sound engineers do not bring up the voices, many which mumble anyways. A whisper is totally lost amidst props being touched moved by the actors, the dialogue volume needs to be enhanced. This is about poor directorship as well as slopping scene engineering and editing with after-effects.

I work on 3D modelling and am in an animation workshop and these are big issues. So it's not about older people being deaf!

Disgruntled Thu 15-Dec-16 10:31:50

Victoria Coren-Mitchell is pretty damn near perfect in so many ways.....????. As is her husband of course - what a fine dynasty in the making. The old fashioned RP was very clear, there's no getting away from it.

PRINTMISS Wed 14-Dec-16 09:13:06

I do not go to the cinema any more either, and always have the sub-titles on, but there again I do wear hearing aids, however the other half is finding it more and more difficult to hear the t.v. (radio is fine) and I am sure they speak far faster than they used to and a lot of presenters these days seem to 'swallow' the last sentences.

Marmark1 Wed 14-Dec-16 08:46:40

I don't go to the cinema,can't understand a word they say,especially American.

MissAdventure Tue 13-Dec-16 19:41:38

I'm sure I read somewhere that people actually do mumble these days.
I find some American programmes difficult to hear.
I did do a phone test of some kind, and my hearing came back as ok.

Tizliz Tue 13-Dec-16 17:32:01

Bad enough that people mumble they then add loud background music

Ana Tue 13-Dec-16 17:29:35

Some dramas (especially BBC ones!) seem to have poor sound quality and the actors are mumbley.

I don't usually have a problem though and can't stand the volume if I ever go to the cinema! shock

Jalima Tue 13-Dec-16 17:08:23

We sometimes use subtitles and turn up the sound -
then Gary Lineker comes on at top volume.
Time to turn off grin

I find Victoria Coren-Mitchell very easy to understand - if only everyone spoke as clearly as she does.

vampirequeen Tue 13-Dec-16 16:46:46

I don't have hearing problems but some TV presenters seem to mumble at times.

Marmark1 Tue 13-Dec-16 16:31:44

Films and drama programs too.Im deaf as a post,wear two hearing aids.But when I watch a old film I can usually hear it.new stuff I rely totally on the subtitles.

jollyg Tue 13-Dec-16 16:25:35

Watching some TV progs, there is a propensity for some presenters to gabble.
A modern occurence, on Radio too,.

Subtitles on TV help, but are the presenters trying to be clever or what.

Radio is a dwam