Gransnet forums

Chat

Is wolf-whistling a sex crime?

(537 Posts)
annsixty Tue 28-Apr-15 08:46:40

The DT is reporting that police are investigating after a young woman complained after "lecherous" builders whistled at her. At risk of being shot down, when I was young and in my prime I would have complained if they didn't whistle at me.

Mishap Sat 02-May-15 19:18:35

I have just returned to this thread, in particular to try and find out what there was in pompa's posts that might be regarded as offensive or objectionable in any way - I can find nothing at all - if there had been then they would have been deleted.

He is expressing a view on how men and women are initially attracted to one another - and I see nothing to argue with there. I was attracted on first sight of my OH to how he looked - it was only much later that I learned about his intelligence, loving nature and extraordinary dry humour.

It is human nature to first see how someone looks and it takes time to appreciate their other qualities.

To address the OP: wolf-whistling is not something I would object to, unless the recipient seemed uncomfortable in some way and then they should stop. It is a time-honoured way of expressing appreciation.

Clearly physically obstructing someone (male or female) is not acceptable.

We cannot become so "right on" that we deny our human natures; or indeed lose our sense of humour.

Come back pompa.

rosequartz Sat 02-May-15 19:06:31

For pompa (but don't whistle it)

www.azlyrics.com/lyrics/deanmartin/standingonthecorner.html

Leticia Sat 02-May-15 19:02:39

I agree kittylester.
I am amazed at the way the thread has gone and that so many people lack a sense of humour!
Don't be bullied pompa- we need more humour- stay with us.

Elegran Sat 02-May-15 18:50:24

And they believed what the priests told them! Then more trouble when it was translated into English and a lot of things were shown to be later additions.

soontobe Sat 02-May-15 18:25:05

Trouble came when people couldnt actually read for themselves.

soontobe Sat 02-May-15 18:23:26

Thats why I always advise people to read the bible themselves, to see what it actually says. Rather than rely on others to say what is actually in the bible.

kittylester Sat 02-May-15 17:54:43

Good posts POGS, grumppa and Elegran!

Elegran Sat 02-May-15 17:51:27

Here it is

Elegran Sat 02-May-15 17:49:38

If anyone missed the series recently on "Sex and the church" or it might have been "The church and sex" then do find it on the net and watch it. An eye-opener on what the bible actually says about sex, and what Jesus said in particular (very little) and how marriage was not a church matter for a long time, but a civil contract between man and woman.

An interesting documentary.

jinglbellsfrocks Sat 02-May-15 17:44:31

Why could it? Explain a bit more.

Elegran Sat 02-May-15 17:43:58

Even worse than taking off the night-shirt !

Ana Sat 02-May-15 17:43:18

Not two holes each though, that could be dodgy! hmm

Elegran Sat 02-May-15 17:42:27

And his socks, jings don't forget his socks.

Ana Sat 02-May-15 17:42:19

Well said, grumppa.

I'm pretty sure when didn't mean magpie123, jingl...

Galen Sat 02-May-15 17:41:54

Might cause friction burns with the fabric?

Elegran Sat 02-May-15 17:41:33

Galen Perhaps two holes? Synchronisation could be difficult in the dark (not easy in the light either)

jinglbellsfrocks Sat 02-May-15 17:40:50

Oh is that what the thread's about?! Yes, I remember now.

jinglbellsfrocks Sat 02-May-15 17:39:33

I suppose it might be like keeping his pj's on.

grumppa Sat 02-May-15 17:39:11

The development of this thread passes belief. An almost light-hearted OP has provoked an intense and often acrimonious debate about wolf-whistling in particular and the nature of men (and women) in general. Pompa tried to introduce a little levity in his customary manner while making a genuine point about human nature, and was roundly abused and bravely defended.

No wonder very few men, apparently, have the cojones to join in on threads like this; we are on a hiding to nothing.

Get a life, everyone; it's not too late, even for grandparents!

jinglbellsfrocks Sat 02-May-15 17:38:35

I don't think anyone could call pomps a "miscreant". smile

Perhaps when meant Magpie123.

Ana Sat 02-May-15 17:38:31

I don't see why/how that would stop either of them enjoying it! confused

Galen Sat 02-May-15 17:38:29

I thought the hole was in the woman's gown? Indecent to bare ones legs you know! Whot?

jinglbellsfrocks Sat 02-May-15 17:36:36

So long as the hole was -

No! Stop it now! shock

jinglbellsfrocks Sat 02-May-15 17:35:42

"...chaste men wore a long night gown with a hole cut in it, so that they could impregnate their wives without (horror) either of them enjoying it"

confused

Would that stop the bloke... Oh, never mind.

Ana Sat 02-May-15 17:23:06

Elegran, you don't mean that no one is around to...er...moderate at all, do you? You'll give people ideas! shock